Money as a Democratic Medium 2.0
June 15-17, 2023
Cambridge and Hamburg Schedules Updated!
Cambridge :: Schedule & Links | Papers | Logistics
Hamburg :: Schedule & Links | Abstracts
Cambridge, MA Conference Schedule
Please note that video captions are auto-generated and may not be accurate. We are working on improving them.
Crossover events with Hamburg, Germany are indicated with red text.
Thursday, June 15, 2023
11:30—1:00
PANEL I: EMERGING SCHOLARS – []
In the Empire’s Shadow: Sovereignty, Public Debt and the Liberalization of Markets in Semi-Peripheral States
COMMENTATOR: Arie Krampf [Remote]
Papers:
- Dana Zuk: “The Distributive Effects of Public Debt: Economic Design, Property Rights and Distribution in the Early Days of Israel”
- Ana Carolina Couto: “What is a Central Bank in Latin America? Debt Negotiations, the IMF, and Monetary Sovereignty”
- Jonathan Katzman: “Advisors, Patrons, or Bullies? American Economists and the Liberalization of the Israeli Economy”
1:00–2:30: CHECK-IN & REFRESHMENTS
1:00—2:30 (Streamed for Cambridge, MA Audience)
HAMBURG ROUNDTABLE
On the Role of Banks, Monetary Policy, and Fiscal Policy in Social Ecological Transformation
Karen Kaiser [Remote](European Central Bank), Andrea Binder [Remote](Berlin), Eric Monnet [Remote](Paris)
CHAIR: Aaron Sahr (HIS)
2:45—3:00
WELCOME
Christine Desan
Opening Cambridge conference
3:00—4:30 (Streamed for Hamburg, Germany Audience 21:00-22:30 CET)
CAMBRIDGE PLENARY:
Climate Alignment for Financial Institutions []
MODERATOR: Sarah Bloom Raskin
PARTICIPANTS: Nate Aden [Remote], Nadav Orian Peer [Remote], Neil Fligstein [Remote]
ABSTRACT: From steel mills to fashion houses, an increasing number of companies have recently pledged to align their greenhouse gas emissions with the reduction goals set in the Paris Agreement. Technical protocols like the Science Based Targets Initiative provide these private actors with detailed guidance on reduction targets, disclosures, and monitoring. As the sector that impacts all other sectors, finance has a central role to play in this emerging framework. In 2021, the UN launched a separate initiative titled Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero to reduce the “financed emissions” associated with financial institutions’ loans and securities. In this moment of institutional flux, the panel will discuss the potential of current efforts to achieve the pace required by the Paris Agreement (50% reductions by 2030, and 100% by 2050). The panel will address the day-to-day workings of financial alignment commitments, the risks of greenwashing, and the scalability of the existing framework to close the global emissions gap. Most fundamentally, the panel will ask whether a framework that ultimately rests on voluntary action by financial institutions is consistent with the sense of urgency and level of coordination required to avoid climate catastrophe.
5:00—6:30
SESSION A: PANEL II (MILSTEIN EAST B) – [Video]
Money and Empire: Past, Present, and Future of the Dollar System
COMMENTATOR: Anush Kapadia
Papers:
- Perry Mehrling: “A Revisionist History of the Dollar System”
- Quinn Slobodian: “Financial Imperialism and Settler Colonialism: Money, Land, and the Career of Dueling Concepts”
- Mehrsa Baradaran: “The Strange Career of Law and Economics”
5:00—6:30
SESSION B: PANEL III (WCC 2004) []
New Critiques of Debt as Social Provision
COMMENTATOR: Pamela Foohey
Papers:
- Patricia McCoy: “Spreading Risk to Attain a Living Income” [Remote]
- Nakita Cuttino: “Escaping Credit Purgatory”
- Chrystin Ondersma: “Dismantling Debt”
- Vijay Raghavan: “Retheorizing Consumer Financial Reform”
5:00—6:30
SESSION C: PANEL IV (WCC 2009) []
Money, Hierarchy, and the Democratic State: Philosophy and Political Economy
COMMENTATOR: Joseph Tinguely
Papers:
- Graham Hubbs: “Some Philosophical Reflections on Monetary Value and Democracy”
- Nina Eichacker: “States in the Money View”
- Aaron James: “Republican Money”
6:30: DINNER
7:30
KEYNOTE (CAMBRIDGE) – [Video]
Professor Saule Omarova, Beth and Marc Goldberg Professor of Law, Cornell Law School
Friday, June 16, 2023
8:00—9:00: BREAKFAST
9:00—10:30 (Hamburg participating 15:00-16:30 CET)
JOINT ROUNDTABLE
Inequality & the Asset Economy – []
CHAIRS: Christine Desan (HLS/Cambridge) / Isabel Feichtner (TNI/Würzburg) [Remote]
PARTICIPANTS: Martijn Konings [Remote], Stephanie Kelton [Remote], Aaron Medlin [Remote], Benjamin Braun [Remote], Anna Chadwick [Remote]
ABSTRACT: Modern economies increasingly appear tilted in favor of asset holders. Credit flows most abundantly to those who can offer enough collateral to secure their loans; concerns about inflation have biased policymakers towards asset-driven growth to the detriment of social spending and wage-increasing measures; and an oligopolistic asset management sector exercises disproportionate power to decide firms’ fates and extract large shares of value. As asset ownership becomes more concentrated and financialization spreads throughout a wide array of industries, many fear that monetary and financial institutional arrangements will exacerbate the wide wealth gap already separating asset-holders from wage-earners. Against this backdrop, the roundtable will explore the relationship between today’s asset-rewarding economy and our alarming levels of income and wealth inequality. Drawing on different disciplines and perspectives, participants in this session will discuss what the ‘asset economy’ is and where it comes from, its connection to capitalism and financialization, its distributive consequences, the myriad mechanisms through which it may generate or exacerbate inequality, and, perhaps most importantly, what to do about it.
10:30—11:00: BREAK
11:00—12:30
SESSION A: PANEL V (MILSTEIN EAST B) – [Video]
Grappling with Hierarchy and Centralization
COMMENTATOR: Anush Kapadia
Papers:
- Alex Howlett: “The Many Faces of Money and Hierarchy”
- Larissa De Lima: “New Technologies, Old Challenges”
- Jay Pocklington: “Managing the International Hierarchy of Money: The Key Currency Approach and its Implications for the Global Public Good”
11:00—12:30
SESSION B: PANEL VI (WCC 2004) []
Teaching and Building Moral Economies of Money
COMMENTATORS: Jacob Feinig & Rohan Grey
Papers:
- Benjamin Wilson: “Money and the Theory of the Firm”
- Lua Yuille: “Teaching Property Law as a Moral Economy of Money”
- Hanna Judson & Julia Ricciardi: “Democratizing Monetary Education Inside and Outside the Classroom: Theory and Practice”
11:00—12:30
SESSION C: PANEL VII (WCC 2009) [No video]
The Big Problem of Petty Coins
COMMENTATOR: Hannah Farber
Papers:
- Brendan Greeley: “Burns against Brimmer: A Missed Chance for a Small-Money Policy at the Fed”
- Rebecca Spang: “Whose Problem Was Small Change? Fractional Currency in Global Contexts”
- Andrew Konove: “Copper, Soap, and Cacao: The Promise and Perils of Small Change in Hispanic America, 1750-1850”
12:30 – 1:30: LUNCH
1:00—2:30
Roundtable on Credit Design & Community Development
MODERATOR: Christine Desan
PARTICIPANTS:
Abe Collins, Land Care Cooperative Chair and CEO
“Credit as a Commons to Heal Our Communities and Watershed Homes – an Invitation” [Slides]
“Credit as a Commons to Heal Our Communities and Watershed Homes – an Invitation” [Slides]
abenewsoil@gmail.com | (802) 782-1883
Susan Witt, Schumacher Center for a New Economics
“Community Issued Currency: a Tool for Relocalizing Economies” [Paper]
centerforneweconomics.org | (413) 528-1737
“Community Issued Currency: a Tool for Relocalizing Economies” [Paper]
centerforneweconomics.org | (413) 528-1737
Nia Evans, Rei Fielder, Cierra Peters, Bob Van Meter, Boston Ujima Project
info@ujimaboston.com | https://www.ujimaboston.com/newsletters
info@ujimaboston.com | https://www.ujimaboston.com/newsletters
ABSTRACT: This roundtable focuses on innovative attempts to redesign credit as a medium that supports community development. In particular, the Land Care Cooperative, BerkShares local currency program, and Boston Ujima Project all work with creative modes of obligation clearing that allow participants to share resources and knowledge. In effect, these new credit modes identify and maximize the mutual credit that can be mobilized locally. At the same time, the modes reduce the amount of external debt, defined as funding offered at interest by the conventional banking system, that participants need to assume. Panelists will explain their schemes, and a community development finance expert will comment on the commonalities and differences between the projects. Subsequent discussion aims to identify how local credit initiatives can or should connect to the larger monetary and credit system; whether local projects can be “scaled”; and how knowledge and design ideas like the ones in this roundtable can be supported and spread.
2:30—4:00
SESSION A: PANEL VIII (MILSTEIN EAST B) – []
Creation of Money by Commercial Banks: What is at Stake?
COMMENTATOR: Perry Mehrling
Papers:
- My Hedlin: “Money-Creating Banks and the Market Price of Time”
- Michael Kumhof: “Central Bank Money: Liability, Asset, or Equity of the Nation?” [Remote]
- Steve Keen: “Creation of Money by Commercial Banks: What is at Stake?”
2:30—4:00
SESSION B: PANEL IX (WCC 2004) []
Money and Social Relations
COMMENTATOR: Sannoy Das
Papers:
- David Wishnick: “The Deep Informatics of Democratic Control over Financial Capital”
- Kevin Crow: “Missing the Medium: Monetary Orders in International (Economic) Legal Theory” [Remote]
- Anush Kapadia: “The Money Fetish: Making Promises Into Things”
- Terri Friedline: “Fintech as Invasive Infrastructure: Critical Discourse Analysis of Corporate Newswires and Press Releases, 1995-2021”
2:30—4:00
SESSION C: PANEL X (WCC 2009) []
The Routine Operation of Financial Markets as Constraining Democracy
COMMENTATOR: Jamee Moudud
Papers:
- Ann Davis: “Global Financial Markets and the Paradoxes of the Public/Private Divide”
- Jesus Hernandez: “Minority Depository Institutions as Tools for Democratizing Money in the US: Challenges of Evolving Technologies and Governance” [Remote]
- Gary Dymski: “Rethinking the Purpose and Scope of Economic Policy in the Post-Covid Era: Nurturing an Economy that is Racially Just by Design” [Remote]
- Nicole Cerpa Vielma: “How the Global Evolution of Financial Markets and Institutions Constrains Democracy and Worsens Inequality in Emerging Markets and Excluded Communities” [Remote]
4:00—4:30: BREAK
4:30—6:00
CAMBRIDGE PLENARY – []
2020 Redux: Expanding the Fed’s Repertoire
MODERATOR: Nicolas Jabko
Participants: Perry Mehrling, Lev Menand, Nathan Tankus, Leah Rose Downey
ABSTRACT: What could the Fed have done differently in 2020 (or 2008 for that matter) to make the distributive consequences of the relief it provided more equitable? Panelists will identify a problematic aspect of the Fed’s action, and then suggest a preferable intervention. The discussion aims to identify a menu of policy alternatives that would work within the existing hardwiring but push those parameters in new and constructive ways. We hope to explore how much (or little) latitude there is within those parameters, given political, institutional, or economic limitations.
6:30: DINNER (TICKETED) – Wasserstein 2nd Fl, Milstein West.
7:30—9:00 APPEAL MEETING (WCC 2004)
Saturday, June 17, 2023
8:00–9:00: BREAKFAST
9:00—10:30 (Streamed for Hamburg, Germany Audience 15:00-16:30 CET) – []
CAMBRIDGE PLENARY
Global Reverberations
MODERATOR: Morgan Ricks
PARTICIPANTS: Ilene Grabel, Carolyn Sissoko, Jonathan Kirshner
In a globalized world, central banks in open economies cannot afford to ignore other monetary authorities’ policies. More recently, the aftermath of two global financial crises and their economic and geopolitical repercussions have once again put the international dimension of central banks’ operations under the spotlight. Should central banks coordinate their monetary tightening efforts and, if so, to what extent? How could their roles be shaped if the U.S. dollar’s hegemonic status as a global reserve currency erodes while other national currencies rise to prominence? What, if anything, could central banks around the world do as the threat of sovereign debt defaults looms larger over the stability of increasingly interconnected financial institutions? Participants in this session will address these and other timely questions as we rethink central banks’ position in international monetary and financial systems.
10:30—11:00: BREAK
11:00—12:30
KEYNOTE – []
Avinash Persaud, Special Envoy to the Prime Minister of Barbados, Mia Amor Mottley
Q&A: Avinash Persaud and Anna Gelpern, Scott K. Ginsburg Professor of Law and International Finance
12:30—1:30: LUNCH
1:30—3:00
SESSION A: PANEL XI (MILSTEIN EAST B) – []
Money in and Out of Economics
COMMENTATOR: David Grewal [remote]
Papers:
- Roni Hirsch: “Politicizing Interest in Nineteenth-Century Political Economy”
- Onur Özgöde: “‘The Chief Stabilizer:’ The Federal Reserve, Macroeconomic Governance, and the Reinvention of Central Banking, 1907-1928”
- Christina Laskaridis: “Where’s the Money? A Historical Look at the Economics of Sovereign Debt and Default”
- Robert Weber: “Three Ways of Looking at the Fed’s Standing Repo Facility”
1:30—3:00
SESSION B: PANEL XII (WCC 2004) []
Lawless Money: Complementary Currencies, Digital Money and Sovereign Power
COMMENTATOR: Coco Kanters [Remote]
Papers:
- Gustav Peebles: “Cosmopolitan vs Provincial Reserves: The Critical Role of Translation in Monetary Policy”
- Daromir Rudnyckyj: “Money as Object, Money as Subject: Limited Liberalism and Community Currency Experiments” [Remote]
- Xue Ma: “People’s Money in Digits: State and Money in Chinese Central Bank Digital Currency” [remote]
3:00—3:30: BREAK
3:30—5:00
SESSION A: PANEL XIII (MILSTEIN EAST B) – []
The Political Lives of Money
COMMENTATOR: Jakob Feinig
Papers:
- David Freund: “What Counts as Money? The Political and Intellectual Origins of M1”
- Katie Moore: “Money Creation and Claims on Money in Early America”
- Ariel Ron [Remote] & Sofia Valeonti: “The Political life of Money during the U.S. Independent Treasury System”
3:30—5:00
SESSION B: PANEL XIV (WCC 2004) []
Payment System Dilemmas/ Trilemmas
COMMENTATOR: Carolyn Sissoko
Papers:
- Dan Awrey: “The Payments Trilemma”
- Sean Vanatta: “Public Money and Private Payments”
- Aaron Klein: “Payments as a Policy Tool”
- Raül Carrillo: “Seeing Through Money: Democracy, Data Governance, and the Digital Dollar”
3:30—5:00
SESSION C: PANEL XV (WCC 2009) []
Dollar Hegemony
COMMENTATOR: Perry Mehrling
Papers:
- Mengyi Wang: “Monetary Curiosity: The Legal, Economic, and Geopolitical Life of the Fed’s Currency Swap Lines”
- John Crawford: “The Dollar Dilemma: Hegemony, Control, and the Dollar’s International Role”
- Stefan Mikuska: “Reclaiming Sovereignty? Dedollarization and Monetary Conflict in Zimbabwe”
- Christine Abely: “The Financial Sanctions and Impact on the Global Financial System”
5:15-6:30
CAMBRIDGE PLENARY – []
After SVB: Proposals for Reform
MODERATOR: Christine Desan
PARTICIPANTS: Morgan Ricks, Tom Ferguson, Rory Van Loo, Devin Fergus, Christine Desan, Plenary/Panel Speakers
Since at least 2008, the Fed, Treasury and the FDIC have taken increasingly controversial steps to support the financial system, including following the recent failure of Silicon Valley Bank. Does this suggest that more far-reaching structural reforms are in order? Panelists will be asked what reforms they would suggest to make money a more “democratic medium” in this time of crisis and uncertainty.
6:45: DINNER